'Shoreline First' regulation incentives

Minnesota is losing 1 – 2 percent of its natural shorelines every decade to riprap, lawns, beaches and other shoreline alterations. These changes eliminate fish and wildlife habitat, remove “up north” character, and accelerate algae growth, especially as our lake waters continue to warm. Protecting and restoring natural shorelines is the single most important action property owners and local governments can take to protect valuable lake and river assets from these losses. To encourage local government adoption of better shoreline protection regulations, the DNR will consider eliminating or modifying some minimum standards.

Better shoreline protection standards

The DNR is encouraging local governments to adopt some or all the following shoreland regulations requiring: 

  • a permit, with standards, for shoreline alterations in the shore impact zone including vegetation removal, sand blankets (beaches), ice ridge removal, and shoreline stabilization

  • a shoreline assessment to determine the best method for shoreline stabilization (e.g. vegetation, bioengineering, riprap) 

  • specific standards for when riprap is allowed and where as well as specific dimensional requirements 

  • installation of stabilization practices consistent with industry standards 

shoreline buffer

  • buffer restoration as a condition of variances, expansion of nonconformities, and shoreline alteration permits 

  • riparian buffer restoration plans with specifications 

  • Shoreland PUD standards that protect, restore, and connect the shore impact zone and other ecologically valuable resources

  • other ideas proposed by local governments

Existing standards to eliminate or modify

To offset the adoption of better standards, the DNR will consider the following changes to local shoreland regulations. 

  • Allowing guest cottages/accessory dwelling units on conforming single lot instead of a duplex lot 

  • Reducing the distance from the OWHL subject to bluff standards 

  • Allowing lateral expansions of nonconforming structures without a variance

  • Eliminating road setback standards 

  • Eliminating most land use requirements

illustration

  • Relaxing amount of open space and number of mooring spaces in shoreland PUDs 

  • Allow stormwater cities to use underlying zoning for density and impervious surface standards for nonriparian lots. Stormwater cities are cities that require existing and future development to be served by a municipal sanitary sewer and manage stormwater under one of the following: 

    • A MS4 permit from the MPCA

    • Metropolitan Surface Water Management Act – MS 103B.201 – 103B.253 and Minnesota Rules 8410 

    • An adopted MIDs ordinance 

  • Other shoreland minimum standards proposed by local government

Approach

DNR welcomes discussions with local governments to develop an agreement on what minimum standard tradeoffs are acceptable for adopting better shoreline standards. There is no one-size-fits-all approach. Each local government has unique administrative capabilities, values, development patterns, and shoreland resources. Here are some considerations: 

  • Past, present, and projected future shoreland development status and pressures (undeveloped, developed, redevelopment, nonconformities) 

  • Predominate condition of existing shorelines – existence of natural shorelines 

  • Topographical, soil, vegetation, ecologically valuable resources, and other characteristics at risk to shoreland development 

  • Specific lake protection needs identified in comprehensive watershed management plans (1W1P), MPCA Watershed Restoration and Protection Strategy (WRAPS) reports, Lake Stressor ID reports by DNR Fisheries (or other lake stressor ID info), landscape level stewardship plans, and/or other assessments. 

  • The technical ability and capacity of the local government to administer the standards. Cooperative arrangements with soil and water conservation districts, watershed organizations, or other resource agencies are resources that can help with this work. 

  • Track record of responsible shoreland regulation administration

The DNR has authority to negotiate modifications to the minimum shoreland standards under Implementation flexibility in Minn. rule 6120.2800 Subp. 3.

Next steps

Contact your Area Hydrologist to learn more and to discuss your ideas.

Back to top